Best MLB DFS Picks For May 8th: Sleepers & Player To Avoid

Viktoria Ivanova

4 min read

Post on May 15, 2025

4.8

Share

Top MLB DFS Sleepers for May 8th

Finding value is key to winning in MLB DFS. These underrated players offer high potential for significant fantasy points based on their matchups, recent performance, and projected statistics. Remember, these are sleepers, so their ownership projections are likely lower than the top-tier players.

• Player 1: Brandon Nimmo (NYM, OF): Nimmo has a fantastic matchup against a pitcher with a high ERA and struggles against left-handed hitters. His recent on-base percentage is high, suggesting consistent production even without home runs. He's a solid value pick for his position. (Projected stats: .300 AVG, 1 HR, 1 RBI)

• Player 2: Alec Bohm (PHI, 3B): Bohm is quietly putting up solid numbers, and he benefits from a favorable park factor at Citizens Bank Park. While not a power hitter, his batting average and consistent production make him a strong sleeper pick at a lower salary. (Projected stats: .280 AVG, 1 RBI, 1 R)

• Player 3: Shane McClanahan (TB, P): While pitchers can be risky in DFS, McClanahan’s matchup against a weak-hitting team makes him a high-value sleeper pick. His strikeout potential is high, which can significantly impact your fantasy score. (Projected stats: 7 K's, 6 IP)

High-Value MLB DFS Plays for May 8th

These top performers offer a high ceiling in terms of fantasy points, but they usually come with a higher salary. Their consistent performance, elite skillset, and favorable matchups justify their higher price tag. Consider them the cornerstones of your MLB DFS lineup.

• Player 1: Shohei Ohtani (LAA, P/DH): Ohtani is a dual-threat superstar. As a pitcher, his strikeout potential is enormous, and as a hitter, he's capable of hitting multiple home runs in a single game. He's a high-risk, high-reward option. (Projected stats: 8 K's, 1 HR, 2 RBI)

• Player 2: Mookie Betts (LAD, OF): Betts is a consistent run producer with a high batting average and power potential. His track record against the opposing pitcher is excellent, making him a safe high-value play. (Projected stats: .350 AVG, 1 HR, 2 RBI)

• Player 3: Aaron Judge (NYY, OF): Judge's power is undeniable. He always carries a high ceiling and the potential to carry your lineup on any given day. His recent form should be carefully considered, but a good matchup could make him a worthwhile investment. (Projected stats: .250 AVG, 1 HR, 2 RBI)

MLB Players to Avoid in Your DFS Lineup on May 8th

Some players are better left on the bench. These players represent higher risk than reward due to poor matchups, injuries, slumping performance, or other negative factors. Avoid these daily fantasy baseball busts to save your lineup.

• Player 1: Juan Soto (SDP, OF): While a talented hitter, Soto is facing a pitcher who has historically dominated him. This poor matchup significantly lowers his potential for production. (Reason: Historically poor performance against opposing pitcher)

• Player 2: Bryce Harper (PHI, OF): Harper's injury history makes him a risky play. While his upside is massive, the potential for a late scratch or limited playing time makes him a player to avoid unless absolutely certain of his availability. (Reason: Injury concerns)

• Player 3: Max Scherzer (NYM, P): While Scherzer is an ace, he's facing a tough lineup, potentially lowering his strikeout numbers and increasing his risk of allowing runs. (Reason: Tough offensive matchup)

Optimizing Your MLB DFS Lineup for May 8th

Building a winning MLB DFS lineup requires strategy. Consider these factors to maximize your chances of winning.

• Balancing High-Value and Sleeper Picks: A good mix of both ensures you have high-ceiling players and value plays to stay under budget.

• Team Stacking Strategies: Stacking 2-3 players from the same team increases your potential payout if that team performs well.

• Positional Diversity: Diversify your lineup with players from different positions to mitigate risk.

• Salary Cap Management: Stay within your salary cap constraints while maximizing your potential points.

Conclusion

Using our best MLB DFS picks for May 8th, focusing on sleepers and avoiding potential busts, will significantly improve your chances of winning. Remember to carefully analyze player matchups, recent performance, and salary constraints.

Ready to dominate your MLB DFS contests on May 8th? Use these expert picks as a foundation and build your winning lineup! Remember to check back for more daily fantasy baseball advice and the best MLB DFS picks.