Canadian Housing Market: Why Few Choose 10-Year Mortgages

Viktoria Ivanova

4 min read

Post on May 04, 2025

4.8

Share

Higher Initial Payments and Qualification Challenges

One of the primary reasons for the low uptake of 10-year mortgages is the significantly higher initial payments and stricter qualification criteria.

Increased Monthly Payments

A 10-year mortgage necessitates much larger monthly payments compared to a traditional 25-year mortgage. This is because the same loan amount is repaid over a shorter period, leading to substantially higher principal payments each month.

• Example: A $500,000 mortgage at a 5% interest rate would result in approximate monthly payments of $4,774 for a 10-year term versus $2,865 for a 25-year term. This represents a difference of nearly $2,000 per month!
• This substantial increase impacts disposable income, potentially limiting lifestyle choices and making it challenging for first-time homebuyers to manage their finances effectively. Many find it difficult to adjust to such a significant financial commitment.
• The impact on first-time homebuyers is particularly pronounced, as they often have less disposable income to begin with.

Stricter Qualification Criteria

Lenders apply stricter requirements to 10-year mortgages due to the increased risk associated with the longer-term commitment.

• Higher Credit Scores: Lenders typically require significantly higher credit scores for 10-year mortgages to mitigate the risk of default.
• Debt-to-Income Ratios: A borrower’s debt-to-income ratio is heavily scrutinized. Lower ratios are necessary to qualify.
• Self-Employed Individuals: Self-employed individuals often face greater difficulty qualifying for a 10-year mortgage due to the perceived higher risk associated with fluctuating income. The need for extensive financial documentation can present challenges.

Uncertainty and Risk Associated with Long-Term Commitments

The unpredictable nature of interest rates and the potential for significant life changes contribute to the hesitation surrounding 10-year mortgages.

Interest Rate Fluctuations

Interest rates are inherently volatile. Locking into a 10-year mortgage means committing to a specific interest rate for an extended period.

• Rate Increases: Interest rates could rise significantly during the 10-year term, potentially leaving borrowers paying more than they would have if they had opted for a shorter-term mortgage and refinanced later.
• Higher Rate Lock-in: Borrowers risk being locked into a higher rate than what might be available in the future. Market conditions can change dramatically over a decade.

Life Changes and Unforeseen Circumstances

Life throws curveballs. Job loss, unexpected medical expenses, or family changes can severely impact a borrower's ability to maintain high mortgage payments for a decade.

• Inflexibility: 10-year mortgages lack the flexibility of shorter-term options. Changing financial circumstances may make it challenging to manage monthly payments.
• Penalties: Breaking a 10-year mortgage early typically involves substantial penalties, making it a costly decision if unforeseen circumstances necessitate a change.

The Appeal of Shorter-Term Mortgages and Refinancing Options

The flexibility and potential for lower interest rates through refinancing make shorter-term mortgages a more appealing option for many Canadians.

Flexibility and Adaptability

Shorter-term mortgages, such as 5-year terms, offer greater flexibility and adaptability.

• Regular Refinancing: Borrowers have the opportunity to refinance every 5 years, taking advantage of potentially lower interest rates.
• Adjusting Payments: If financial circumstances change, borrowers can adjust their mortgage payments during the refinancing process.

Potential for Lower Interest Rates

Refinancing after the initial term offers the potential for significant savings.

• Rate Reductions: If interest rates fall during the 5-year period, borrowers can refinance at a lower rate, reducing their monthly payments.
• Savings: This can lead to substantial savings over the lifetime of the mortgage.

Conclusion

Canadians are less inclined to choose 10-year mortgages due to higher payments, the uncertainty of interest rate fluctuations, and the inflexibility of a long-term commitment. The appeal of shorter-term mortgages and the ability to refinance at potentially lower rates outweigh the perceived long-term savings for many homebuyers. Choosing the right mortgage, whether it's a 10-year mortgage or a shorter-term option, is crucial in the Canadian housing market. Consult a financial advisor to explore your options and determine the best mortgage strategy for your individual circumstances.