Is This The Planet Star Wars Fans Have Waited 48 Years To See?

Viktoria Ivanova

4 min read

Post on May 16, 2025

4.1

Share

Visual Comparisons: Does Exegol Meet the Fan Expectations?

Exegol, the Sith planet introduced in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, presents a stark contrast to the vibrant worlds we've seen previously. Its visual design significantly departs from the lush landscapes of planets like Kashyyyk or the bustling cities of Coruscant. Let's compare its aesthetic to what fans have envisioned over the years:

• Dark and Desolate: Unlike the vibrant green of Dagobah or the arid beauty of Tatooine, Exegol is characterized by a dark, almost gothic aesthetic. This aligns with some fan expectations for a hidden Sith stronghold, but deviates from the more diverse planetary landscapes many had hoped for.
• Imposing Structures: The imposing, decaying structures of Exegol evoke a sense of ancient power and forgotten history. While impressive in their scale, some fans feel the design leans too heavily on established Star Wars scenery tropes, lacking originality.
• Color Palette: The predominantly dark gray, black, and crimson color palette contributes to the planet's foreboding atmosphere. This choice, while fitting thematically, might disappoint some who were hoping for a more visually diverse Star Wars planet.
• Comparison to Fan Concepts: Many fan-made planets feature unique biomes and architectural styles. While Exegol is visually striking, it doesn't entirely capture the imaginative breadth of these fan-created worlds, potentially leaving some fans wanting more.

The Lore and Story: A Worthy Addition to the Star Wars Galaxy?

Exegol's significance within the Star Wars storyline is undeniable. It serves as the hidden base of the resurrected Sith Eternal, offering a compelling narrative arc within the sequel trilogy. However, does its lore meet fan expectations?

• Ancient Sith History: The planet's connection to ancient Sith history adds a layer of depth to the Star Wars canon. This exploration of a previously unknown aspect of the Sith's past fulfills a long-standing desire among fans for more insight into the order's origins.
• The Sith Eternal: The introduction of the Sith Eternal introduces a new faction within the Star Wars history, adding complexity to the established lore. However, some might argue that this new addition feels somewhat rushed and lacks the detailed development many hoped for in a mythical Star Wars planet.
• Lack of Exploration: Despite its pivotal role in the story, Exegol's exploration felt limited, leaving fans wanting a more in-depth look at its culture, inhabitants, and hidden secrets. Many hoped for a new Star Wars planet rich in mystery and with a vibrant culture to explore.
• Connection to Existing Canon: While adding to the broader Star Wars storyline, some felt Exegol's inclusion felt somewhat disconnected from the established lore, lacking organic integration within the existing canon.

Cultural Impact and Fan Reactions: Has the Wait Been Worth It?

The reaction to Exegol within the Star Wars community has been mixed. Social media platforms and fan forums reveal a spectrum of opinions:

• Positive Reactions: Many fans appreciated Exegol's dark and mysterious atmosphere, praising its contribution to the overall narrative of The Rise of Skywalker.
• Negative Reactions: Others found Exegol to be visually underwhelming and narratively underdeveloped, feeling it fell short of the potential for a truly memorable Star Wars planet.
• Prevalent Themes: Common criticisms include a lack of exploration, a reliance on established tropes, and a feeling that the planet's potential wasn't fully realized. Fan theories abound, suggesting alternate interpretations and potential storylines that could have enriched Exegol's portrayal.

The Verdict on the New Star Wars Planet

Exegol, while undeniably significant to the Star Wars storyline, presents a mixed bag for fans. Its dark aesthetic and connection to ancient Sith history fulfill certain expectations, while its limited exploration and potentially rushed narrative leave some feeling underwhelmed. Whether this new Star Wars planet lives up to the hype of 48 years of anticipation remains a subject of ongoing discussion within the Star Wars community. It's a true Star Wars planet in terms of its role in the saga, but is it the Star Wars planet fans have been waiting for? That's ultimately a matter of personal interpretation.

What are your thoughts on this new Star Wars planet? Let us know in the comments! Is this the Star Wars planet you've been dreaming of? Discuss below!