John Wick 5: Exploring The Impossibility Of John Wick's Comeback

Viktoria Ivanova

5 min read

Post on May 12, 2025

4.7

Share

The Physical Toll of Being the Baba Yaga

John Wick's relentless battles have taken a significant toll. Each film showcases increased injuries and a growing weariness. A fifth film would necessitate pushing Keanu Reeves's physical limits further, potentially impacting the film's realism and his well-being.

Exhaustion and Aging

• Increased reliance on weapons over close-quarters combat: As John ages, we might see a shift in his fighting style, relying more on guns and less on brutal hand-to-hand combat. This could alter the signature John Wick action sequences.
• Visible signs of aging and injury: The films could realistically depict the accumulating effects of years of fighting, showing scars, limping, or other physical limitations that impact his capabilities.
• Slower movement: The iconic speed and agility of John Wick might be lessened, adding a layer of vulnerability and realism to his character.
• Potential need for more stunt doubles: To protect Keanu Reeves and maintain a level of action, the filmmakers may need to rely more heavily on stunt doubles, potentially affecting the audience's connection with the character.

The Diminishing Returns of Plot Armor

While John Wick possesses incredible skills, even he cannot defy death indefinitely. The increasingly improbable escapes and near-misses in previous films raise the question of how much plot armor can realistically sustain another installment.

• Analyzing the escalating stakes of each film: Each film raises the stakes higher than the last. To justify a fifth, the stakes would have to be even higher, potentially pushing the boundaries of credibility.
• Exploring the likelihood of surviving increasingly improbable situations: The sheer number of enemies John Wick dispatches becomes increasingly unbelievable with each sequel. A fifth film needs to address this escalating improbability.
• The diminishing believability of his continued survival: The audience's suspension of disbelief can only stretch so far. Continued survival against overwhelming odds risks undermining the narrative's impact.

Narrative Exhaustion and Story Fatigue

The core narrative structure of the John Wick films—a wronged assassin seeking revenge—risks becoming formulaic. A fifth film needs to offer a significant narrative shift to avoid feeling repetitive and predictable.

Repeating the Formula

• Potential for a change in storyline: Instead of another revenge plot, perhaps John Wick could be protecting someone, or even mentoring a new generation of assassins.
• Exploring a more personal narrative beyond revenge: Delving deeper into John's past, his relationships, and his motivations could provide a fresh narrative angle.
• Expanding upon the High Table's complexities: Exploring the internal politics and power struggles within the High Table could provide richer narrative opportunities.

The High Table's Unending Power

John Wick's enemies, especially the High Table, seem infinitely powerful and resourceful. Consistently defeating them necessitates increasingly improbable scenarios, weakening the narrative's overall impact.

• The need for a new, significant threat: Introducing a new antagonist or a completely different type of conflict could reinvigorate the story.
• Exploring limitations of the High Table's influence: Showing the High Table's vulnerabilities or internal conflicts could make the narrative more believable.
• A possible shift in power dynamics: Perhaps John Wick could even become part of the High Table, leading to a fascinating internal conflict.

The Audience's Expectation and Critical Acclaim

Each successive film must maintain a high standard of action choreography, storytelling, and character development to satisfy the audience. A poorly executed John Wick 5 could damage the franchise's legacy.

Maintaining Quality and Avoiding a Franchise Burnout

• Analyzing critical reception of previous films: The critical success of previous films sets a high bar for a fifth installment.
• Addressing fan expectations and concerns: Addressing the audience's concerns regarding plot armor and repetitive storylines is crucial.
• Exploring potential story arcs that would justify a fifth installment: A compelling story is necessary to warrant another film.

The Risk of Oversaturation

Releasing too many films in a franchise can lead to audience fatigue and diminish the impact of the earlier installments. A John Wick 5 needs to offer something genuinely new and compelling to justify its existence.

• Analyzing other action franchises and their longevity: Studying successful and unsuccessful action franchises can provide insights.
• Exploring the potential risk of oversaturating the market: Too many films can dilute the brand and reduce audience interest.
• The importance of quality over quantity: A smaller number of high-quality films is preferable to many mediocre ones.

Conclusion

While the prospect of another John Wick adventure is exciting, a careful examination of the narrative, character arc, and physical demands suggests that a truly satisfying John Wick 5 might be impossible. The Baba Yaga’s incredible resilience has pushed the boundaries of believability, and continued success requires a substantial shift in approach. Perhaps a spin-off or a carefully crafted final chapter might be more suitable than trying to force a potentially underwhelming comeback. The question remains: can a fifth installment truly justify itself, or is it time to let John Wick rest? What do you think are the possibilities for a successful John Wick 5? Share your thoughts on a potential John Wick 5 and whether you believe a comeback is truly possible.